PUTNEY DEBATER
A personal blog
Gilbey on Film: Chronicle of Protest, previewed
Activist video is providing a corrective to the mainstream media – but nothing beats the power of a cinema screen.
One of the qualities I love about cinema is its assertiveness: it’s so much harder to overrule or ignore a film when it’s on a cinema screen, whether that screen is in the Grand Palais in Cannes or the Slough Cineworld, than when it’s on television, laptop or iPod. I was impressed when I watchedChronicle of Protest, the omnibus edition of Michael Chanan’s attentivevideo blogs for the NS, on DVD this week. But its real power will become apparent, I suspect, only when it is screened in a cinema, as it will be this Saturday as part of the East End Film Festival.
Chanan’s blogs have already contributed to the democratising of the media by drawing heavily on amateur videos, shot by activists on the various protests and sit-ins which have engulfed and energised the country since the coalition government came to power. Moving that material to a cinema screen provides a kind of ratification that is pleasantly at odds with the film’s urgent, snapshot feel.
The idea behind the commission, if I understand it correctly, was to provide a coherent picture of the mood of protest. Mainstream media can only fragment and dissipate such a groundswell, filtering each separate demonstration through its own agenda. (One example highlighted by some of the film’s interviewees is the bizarre way in which the unhappy travel experiences of two members of the Royal Family became the focal point of the protest against the hoisting of tuition fees.) Chronicle of Protest goes some way toward being a corrective to this.
Through some nifty editing and lucid rhetoric, the connections between the actions of the coalition and the hardships imposed on communities become transparent. A level-headedness emerges in the judicious cutting of scenes which another documentary might have played straight; I especially liked the way Chanan cuts back and forth between the temperate oratory of Terry Eagleton and the incendiary scenes of protestors storming Jeremy Hunt’s appearance at the LSE. Laurie Penny of the NS reflects that the government is rather like a spider, in that it is more scared of us than we are of it, and Chanan helpfully replays in slow-motion close-up a shot of Hunt looking mortified as the room is besieged.
I also liked the material showing another of this magazine’s writers, Mehdi Hasan, imagining at the podium what he would do to attack the government if he were Ed Miliband. I express no favouritism to Mehdi, whom I have met only once (I believed we discussed Terminator-related matters), when I say that his address gives the film an extra jolt of fiery energy. (Later, Chanan films an interview with him from a suspiciously low angle, as though Mehdi is being stung in a Panorama exposé, perhaps on a cash-for-guest-editorships scandal.)
One thing I didn’t like about this otherwise involving film was its framing device of performances by the First of May Band, whose compositions (“Hey there, Mr Banker Man/ You don’t look so great/ Someone ought to tell you/ You’re past your sell-by date”) seem too simplistic to provide more than a cosmetic reflection of the woes documented on screen.
Clarion calls for activism
Morning Star
Clarion calls for activism
A joint venture between the New Statesman magazine and Roehampton University, Michael Chanan’s Chronicle of Protest is the first documentary to look at the burgeoning anti-cuts movement in Britain.
It’s a film that Chanan hopes will be viewed as “a bit dangerous” by the ruling order because of its wholehearted celebration of the protest movement.
Beginning in November 2010 and ending with the massive TUC-organised demo last month, it’s a whistle-stop tour of the assorted resistance to the deepest public spending cuts since the second world war.
Many of the rising stars of the new movement appear including comedian Josie Long, ex-Morning Star journo Laurie Penny, UK Uncut, influential website False Economy and academic Nina Power who notes that “we are fighting against an incredibly brutal, fast attempt to eradicate anything that has any social dimension, any non-profit dimension.”
While the trade unions and Tony Benn are featured, this is undoubtedly a movement propelled forward by young people, from the students involved in university occupations to those creatively protesting against the tax-dodgers on our high street.
“The government is very much like a spider,” Penny says about her involvement in heckling Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt MP at the London School Of Economics. “It is actually more frightened of us than we are frightened of it.”
Soundtracked by the sloganeering First of May Band and mixing Chanan’s own footage with activist videos, Chronicle of Protest makes a valiant effort to capture the politics and energy of the movement.
But in its attempt to be bang up to date and focusing on several sites of ongoing resistance – universities, libraries, art galleries and banks – the film is sometimes a mish-mash of images and interviews, with arguments not always fully followed through.
Yet the anti-cuts movement is by its very diverse and leaderless nature a difficult beast to summarise and film coherently.
It’s too early to draw any firm conclusions about the outcome of the resistance to the government’s cuts agenda. But this exciting film is an impressive attempt at documenting and making sense of this tumultuous time in British history.
Source: Clarion calls for activism / Film / Culture / Home – Morning Star
Address : http://www.morningstaronline.co.uk/news/content/view/full/103984
Reading Montaigne in 2011
What is going on, culturally speaking, when a person finds themself reading a classic text from say the 16th century, like Montaigne’s Essays, in the form of a 21st century electronic book?
Read more
